Tuesday, February 15, 2011

A book review: Muses, Madmen, and Prophets

One of the first things I remember about writing is that you are supposed to identify your audience. In this case, who might be interested in reading this book? So I think you will like this book if you are interested in any of the following: Religion, Philosophy, Linguistics, Mental Health, Neurology, Art, History, or Bathroom Humor (okay that last one is just to get a select few people to read further; you know who you are). If none of this applies then you are free to move on.

I picked up Muses, Madmen, and Prophets: Rethinking the History, Science, and Meaning of Auditory Hallucination, by Daniel B. Smith at a used bookstore, because I'm a nerd who likes to read about things I deal with at work, even in my free time. The reason I think this book works is that the author, a journalist by profession, mixes his personal experience living with a father who heard voices with a pretty impressive and thorough reading of science, history, and philosophy. He examines historical figures including Socrates, Joan of Arc, several of the Old Testament prophets, and many others. He also talks with several people who hear voices and does a good job describing their experience. Most of the subject matter returns to the same question; is hearing voices always indicative of mental illness?

After reading this book I felt more knowledgeable in all the areas I mentioned above. I think the book advances a more compassionate view of mental illness, while also acknowledging how our attitudes towards those who hear voices might be biased by a narrow view of this experience. Also, if you follow the link above you will find that the book is on sale at Amazon.com for less that $4. Not sure how you can beat that. If you read it or have read it, feel free to leave some comments below.